Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Personal tools
Log in
Sections
You are here: Home Volume XII June 2013 Equipment Review: LED Lighting Tests: Maxspect Razor, Aquatic Life Expert Series, and Tao-Tronics

Equipment Review: LED Lighting Tests: Maxspect Razor, Aquatic Life Expert Series, and Tao-Tronics

By Sanjay Joshi, Ph.D. Posted Jun 12, 2013 11:00 AM Pomacanthus Publications, Inc.
Continuing in the same vein as my previous LED lighting tests, this article presents data on light intensity and spread along with spectral plots for several new LED fixtures.

LEDtest2a.jpg

New LED fixtures continue to be introduced into the hobby. Specifically, there has been an increase in the number of LED fixtures providing a more fuller color spectrum with multiple channels of control, allowing the user more freedom in custom tuning the light output. Continuing in the same vein as my previous LED lighting tests, this article presents data on light intensity and spread along with spectral plots for several new LED fixtures. Table 1 presents a list of the LED lighting fixtures reviewed in this article. Each of these was tested using the same set up as my previous reflector tests, using a 3'X3' grid with a spacing of 3" in the X,Y direction. The fixtures were centered on this grid, and PAR was measured as PPFD (Photosynthetic Photon Flux Density) in micromoles/m2/sec using a LICOR 1000 data logger and a LI-192SA underwater cosine corrected sensor calibrated for both air and water. The data logger was set to average 5 readings for each data collection point. The data was imported into Microsoft Excel for analysis and the data was plotted to display the light spread and intensity at various distances. 4 plots of the data with 2 plots at each distance were generated showing:

  • A 3-D surface plot showing the actual PAR values recorded
  • A contour plot viewing the surface from the top showing the distribution

The spectral distributions were measured using the Licor LI-1800 spectroradiometer. The spectral data was collected from the various LEDs and normalized such that integrated light output (spectral irradiance) between the wavelengths of 400-700 nm was 100 Watts/m2. Data was collected at full power output for the individual channels of light control (eg. Blue, white) along with data with ALL LEDs on at full power. The data was normalized so that the total irradiance was at 100 Watts/m2 over the wavelength range 400-700 nm. The various LED color outputs were then scaled by the same scale factor to allow of determination of the contribution of the various LEDs to the full output. The results are plotted as a Spectral power distribution plot.

Table 1: LED Lighting Fixtures Tested
None None
Maxspect

Razor

R240R

M16000

image001.jpg
Tao Tronics

TTAL01

image005.jpg
Aquatic Life

Expert Series

14"

image003.jpg

The fixtures were tested for light spread and intensity at 24"and 30", unless otherwise noted. Power draw was measured with a Kill-A-Watt meter.

 

Test Data and Analysis

Maxspect Razor (R420R M16000)

The Maxspect Razor (R420R M16000) is built with a very slim profile, and is one of the thinnest LED fixtures in the market. The unit tested is the M16000, based on its advertised rating of 16000K color temperature. The unit has 2 channels of control with the following LEDs arranged in the 2 channels, as shown by their specifications in Figure 1 below.

figure_1_maxspect_razor_leds.jpg

Figure 1. Maxspect R420R M16000 LEDs and Assignment to Channels of Control

These leds are arranged in 3 sets (or clusters) with the pattern in each set as shown in Figure 2.

figure_2_razor_led_arrangement.jpg

Figure 2. Arrangement of LEDs in each cluster

figure_3_maxspect_razor_par_distribution.jpg

Figure 3. Maxspect R420R, Light Intensity and Distribution at 24" and 30"

figure_4_maxspect_razor_spectrum.jpg

Figure 4: Spectral Distribution of Maxspect Razor M16000

The power consumption as measured by the Kill-A-Watt meter is shown in the table below.

Maxspect Razor (R420R M16000)
Watts 192
Amps 2.65
Volts 123.3

 

Aquatic Life Expert Series 14"

The Aquatic life Expert series 14" model comprises 24 Cree LED`s: 8-White XPG, 8-Blue XPE, 6-Royal Blue XPE and 2-Red XPE, arranged as shown in Figure 5. The LEDs can be controlled through the The T-Time Software which enables custom programming of the LEDs. . Included in this customization is the ability to create 18 different light color combinations, three 24 hr cycles, control cloud cover, lightning storms and lunar light. Once programmed, the Light Fixture is controlled with the handheld remote.

figure_5_aquatic_life_led_arrangement.jpg

Figure 5 Aquatic Life Expert Series 14" showing the arrangement of the different color LEDs

figure_6_aquatic_life_par_distribution.jpg

Figure 6. Aquatic Life XS 14" Light Intensity and Distribution at 24" and 30"

figure_7_aquatic_life_spectrum.jpg

Figure 7. Aquatic Life XS 14" Spectrum Distribution

The power consumption as measured by the Kill-A-Watt meter is shown in the table below.

Aquatic Life XS
Watts 90
Amps 1.34
Volts 123.5

 

Tao Tronics - TTAL01 Aquarium Coral Reef Tank LED White and Blue

  • Number of Lights: blue(25*3w LED); white(30*3w LED)
  • Blue: 460-470nm wavelength; White: 12,000-14,000K color temperature

The Tao Tronics has 55 3W LEDs are arranged in an array with 5 rows and 11 columns, with each column containing LEDs of the same color, with 5 columns of Blue LEDs (Total 25) in the 460-470 nm range, and 6 columns of white LEDs (total 30) in the 12000-14000K color range, arranged as shown in Figure 8. The LEDs are operated at around 2W. The controls are simple with 2 channels each allowing ON/OFF control via 2 power cords. One power cord controls the blue and the other the white LEDs as shown in Figure 9. The unit is air cooled with 3 fans..

figure_8_tao_tronics_picture.jpg

Figure 8. Tao Tronic LED arrangement of the different color LEDs

figure_9_tao_tronics_back.jpg

Figure 9. Back side of the Tao Tronics Fixture showing the 3 fans and 2 power cords for the 2 channels of ON/OFF control.

figure_10_tao_tronics_par_distribution.jpg

Figure 10. Tao Tronics PAR Distribution at 24" and 30"

figure_11_tao_tronics_spectrum.jpg

Figure 11. Tao Tronics Spectrum

The power consumption as measured by the Kill-A-Watt meter is shown in the table below.

Tao Tronics
Watts 111
Amps .97
Volts 122.2

 

Discussion and Conclusions

The 3 LEDs tested here, represent a wide range in light output as well as price points. Based on the data the cheaper Tao Tronic LEDs do not use any optics and hence the light measurements at 24" and 30" are quite low compared to the other 2. A light such as this only provides white and blue LEDs and is mostly suitable for shallower tanks with the LED fixtures mounted close to the top of the tanks. The Maxspect Razor is an attractively styled light with 6 different LED colors, however the control capabilities are limited to 2 channels. The power draw is fairly high at 192W even though the fixture rating is 160W. The higher power does translate into more light output than the others at distances of 24" and 30". The Aquatic Life Expert Series 14" fixture also provides 4 different LEDs that can be controlled individually through their control software that runs on a computer. Given that is a smaller fixture, the light distribution is smaller than the larger Maxspect Razor. The Aquatic Life Expert Series is also available in larger sizes. The data provided should be useful to aquarists making decisions on LED lighting for their reefs.

Document Actions
blog comments powered by Disqus
ADVANCED AQUARIST